Florida International University officials faced strong opposition Friday to a recently revealed cooperation agreement between campus police and U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement during an emergency meeting of the school’s faculty senate.
Interim President Jeanette Nuñez briefly addressed faculty representatives, hoping to address “much confusion, much angst, and much misinformation” about the agreement between the school and Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials.
FIU’s police department was complying with Gov. Ron DeSantis’ order that all state law enforcement agencies enter a cooperation agreement with ICE, she said.
Last month, the University of Florida and the University of South Florida confirmed that they had entered similar agreements. At least 10 Florida schools had done so, Inside Higher Ed reported Wednesday. Even the 700-student New College has complied.
Friday’s meeting was likely the most open and frank discussion of the controversial agreements at a state university.
Nuñez also sought to clarify that the 18 FIU students whose visas were revoked, as first reported by the Miami New Times, were not related to the ICE agreement under discussion.
“Those are two totally separate and distinct issues. The F-1 visa revocations are decisions that are made strictly under the purview of the federal government, solely with their authority. FIU has nothing to do with that,” Nuñez said before turning the microphone over to Campus Chief of Police Alexander Casas.
Over the course of the two-hour meeting, Casas attempted to mollify faculty concerns, explaining that entering into an agreement with federal immigration officials grants him more control over how enforcement actions are carried out on campus.
“If (ICE) has the name of an FIU student who resides on campus, I want them to call us first,” Casas said. “I want to be, as much as possible, in the driver’s seat. Without the agreement, I’m not even in the car.”
Casas appealed to what he portrayed as the department’s collaborative approach to policing the Miami campus during the Black Lives Matter protests and student actions in response to the ongoing conflict in Gaza.
“You saw a very different police response from us than what happened at Columbia or even at USF,” he said. “In three years, I’ve never had a use-of-force incident at FIU. That’s a record that any chief in the country would beg to have, and it has to do with how we interact with our community.”
FIU has sent a signed agreement letter to ICE officials, identical to a template letter available on the agency’s website. However, he conceded that he can’t predict how involved federal officials will be in enforcing immigration orders until his department receives further guidance and training.
“I want to be straight up with you. I can’t control what ICE does,” he said. “I don’t see a scenario, and I don’t see the inference, of an ICE supervisor standing next to my officer as they’re conducting any kind of activity.”
Faculty responses were uniformly negative.
“I worry that you’ve made a grievous mistake,” one faculty member said during a Q-and-A portion of the meeting. “At the front of ICE’s efforts is the place we don’t want you to be. There will be costs to leading this that will degrade other efforts to keep the campus safe.”
Another pointed out that the memorandum indicates that campus police will be supervised and directed by ICE and requires the school to provide immigration officials “access to appropriate databases, personnel, individuals in custody, and documents,” according to the template agreement.
“That kinda sounds like they say ‘jump’ and you say ‘how high,’” he said.
Friday’s meeting was preceded by a demonstration by roughly 50 FIU faculty and staff, organized by United Faculty of Florida, carrying signs reading “No ICE on campus” and “Paws off our students.”
“This is a threat to the university at many different levels,” said Tania Cepero Lopez, an associate teaching professor of writing and rhetoric and president of FIU’s faculty union.
“As a majority-minority university, how can our students feel safe in our community if they feel they can be stopped and questioned about their immigration status at any time?” Lopez said.
When asked if she felt it was realistic to expect the university to back out of its agreement with ICE, Lopez responded that her organization “can mobilize people to stop the agreement from happening. If it goes forward, we can provide information.”
“But what is realistic? I don’t know anymore,” she said. “We’re in uncharted territory.”